Mattson 1 Do Electoral Systems Affect Female Representation? Comparing the Proportion of Women in Rwandan and Tanzanian Legislatures
نویسندگان
چکیده
With increased calls for equal representation of the sexes in government throughout the world, various countries have employed gender-quota systems in their national legislatures. One such country, Rwanda, has achieved the number one rank of proportion of women in its national parliament, with 56.3 percent being women. However other countries, despite making similar attempts through enacting gender quota systems, have not been as successful as Rwanda. For example, Tanzania is tied for rank number twenty on the global scale with 36 percent of its national parliament being women (Women in Parliaments). As both similar countries took measures to increase female representation in national parliament by implementing gender quota systems, why has one been more successful than the other? Pippa Norris' theory that electoral systems affect the proportion of women in government best answers this question. In my paper, I will first present why Rwanda and Tanzania are comparable countries. As the two are similar to each other in many regards, including type of government and economy, one would expect them to have equal levels of female representation. However, in Tanzania, the female members of parliament almost exclusively hold the seats reserved for them, whereas in Rwanda women are running for and winning open seats in parliament. I will address a solution that other scholars have put forth to answer this puzzle, that Rwanda's genocide accounts for this difference, and explain why it is incorrect. As the notable difference between the two countries is in their electoral systems, with Rwanda having a proportional representation system and Tanzania having a single member district plurality system, I will argue that Pippa Norris' theory,
منابع مشابه
The Impact of Electoral Reform on Women’s Representation
One concern about reform of the electoral system in the Netherlands is whether this would reduce the proportion of women members in the House of Representatives. What evidence is there for this expectation? This study considers these issues, with the first section summarizing the normative arguments why socially inclusive legislatures are thought to be desirable. The representation of women in ...
متن کاملElectoral Systems and the Legislative Representation of Muslim Ethnic Minority Women in the West, 2000–2010
Despite growing interest from practitioners, politicians and the media, the political representation of Muslim ethnic minority women in the West has received scant scholarly attention. I address this gap with new data on the representation of Muslim ethnic minority women and men in 20 national legislatures from 2000 to 2010. Results reveal that Muslim ethnic minority women are increasingly elec...
متن کاملThe effects of electoral systems on women’s representation in post-communist states
This paper examines the relationship between electoral systems and female representation in four post-communist states that use mixed electoral systems. Mixed electoral systems provide an excellent laboratory to test electoral system effects because voters cast two ballots under very different electoral rules. If the PR and SMD tiers of mixed elections are treated separately, one can study the ...
متن کاملIranian Women, Inside or Outside of the Stadium? An Anthropological Study on Female Representation of National Identity in Iran
A controversial and comprehensive debate that has resulted in numerous discursive clashes in Iran pertains to the presence of women at stadiums during male soccer matches. Different discourse systems have expressed their own contradictory and opposite stances in terms of whether Iranian women have the right to attend such events inside or outside the stadium, ranging from different notions of r...
متن کاملHanding the Microphone to Women: Changes in Gender Representation in Editorial Contributions Across Medical and Health Journals 2008-2018
The editorial materials in top medical and public health journals are opportunities for experts to offer thoughts that might influence the trajectory of the field. To date, while some studies have examined gender bias in the publication of editorial materials in medical journals, none have studied public health journals. In this perspective, we studied the gender ratio ...
متن کامل